浪花直播

Haiti: Where the Descendants of Slaves Paid the Descendants of Slaveholders

Image - Addressing Governance Challenges in Haiti

Haiti, one of the world鈥檚 poorest countries, was forced to pay France 112 million francs (approximately  in today鈥檚 money) for recognition of its independence and sovereignty.
 

What do Americans think of when they hear the name 鈥淗aiti?鈥 They may be aware that it has received more than its share of natural disasters over the years, from  to  to  (and more). They may have read some of the  of extraordinarily violent criminal gangs being in control of neighborhoods and communities. And all of this has probably led some to believe that the situation there is not only hopeless, but that the Haitian people somehow brought this upon themselves.

What very few Americans realize is that Haiti鈥檚 early post-colonial development was largely destroyed when the country was straddled with a crushing debt it was forced to take on by outside powers.

Haiti was once a prosperous French colony that, thanks largely to slave labor, produced huge profits and wealth for its masters. In 1823, just under two decades after Haitians formally declared its independence, France鈥檚 King Charles X sent a fleet of warships into Haitian waters with a demand that Haiti pay France  in exchange for recognizing its sovereignty and in compensation for the loss of French profits derived from Haiti鈥檚 plantations. To put that into context, the United States only paid the equivalent of 15 million francs for the Louisiana Purchase 20 years earlier. 

While the amount Haiti was to pay was eventually negotiated down to 90 million francs, a New York Times investigation concluded that Haiti likely ended up paying France 112 million francs (or approximately  in modern US dollars). While it鈥檚 difficult to state with certainty what Haiti could have accomplished in economic development had it not been forced to pay its former occupier, a New York Times鈥 analysis reviewed and supported by 14 financial historians and economists calculated that these funds could conservatively have added  to Haiti鈥檚 modern economy. 

Haiti made regular payments to France for  under the terms of its arrangement with King Charles X鈥 money that didn鈥檛 finance schools, infrastructure, and other types of economic and governance development. 

Among those who ended up receiving some of the money that Haitian citizens put out鈥攍argely composed of former slaves and the descendants of slaves鈥 Empress of Brazil, the son-in-law of Russian Emperor Nicholas I, Germany鈥檚 last imperial chancellor, and French General Gaston de Galliffet. 

To get a sense of how Haiti鈥檚 forced payments did so much damage to its fledgling economy, Haiti鈥檚 very first payment to France was  than the young country鈥檚 entire annual revenue. In order to be able to comply with its debt terms, the Haitian government took out high interest loans from a range of banks in France, but also banks in the US and other parts of Europe. This created a double debt: the original debt owed to France, and a growing debt owed to foreign lenders.

Several years ago, when I was visiting Haiti in my capacity as the administrator of the US Agency for International Development, I took a helicopter flight from Port au Prince to a nearby community. As we flew low over some of the country鈥檚 poorest neighborhoods鈥攁reas that looked like they were war-ravaged鈥擨 asked my pilot, 鈥淗ow do I describe what I鈥檓 seeing to people back home鈥 people in the US?鈥 He paused for a moment, and said, 鈥淎t 500 feet, Haiti is a Caribbean Island.鈥 

In other words, Haiti is in a beautiful part of the world, and it鈥檚 a country that could and should be a thriving tourist mecca. But it isn鈥檛. And while there are many factors that have contributed to Haiti鈥檚 plight, the country鈥檚 early years, when former slaves were forced to pay their former masters, has to be one of those reasons鈥 and one of the most shameful. 

Innocent families in Haiti are still feeling the consequences.

This blog was researched and drafted with assistance from Chelsea Acheampong and Katherine Schauer. 

Latin America Program

浪花直播鈥檚 prestigious Latin America Program provides non-partisan expertise to a broad community of decision makers in the United States and Latin America on critical policy issues facing the Hemisphere. The Program provides insightful and actionable research for policymakers, private sector leaders, journalists, and public intellectuals in the United States and Latin America. To bridge the gap between scholarship and policy action, it fosters new inquiry, sponsors high-level public and private meetings among multiple stakeholders, and explores policy options to improve outcomes for citizens throughout the Americas. Drawing on the 浪花直播 Center鈥檚 strength as the nation鈥檚 key non-partisan policy forum, the Program serves as a trusted source of analysis and a vital point of contact between the worlds of scholarship and action.   Read more

Latin America Program