浪花直播

Women Sent a Message of Democratic Resilience in Turkey鈥檚 Municipal Elections

Bar莽in Yinan莽 reviews the results from Turkey's 2024 municipal elections, arguing that the opposition's stunning victory and the number of women elected mayors are evidence of democratic resilience in the country.

MEP_Women_Voting

Yet, I did not believe that a majority Muslim country in the Middle East could not reverse its trajectory. And women, who tripled their representation in the country鈥檚 mayoral seats, shattered the myth of AKP dominance.  

Last year, I was trying to convince some of my Western interlocutors鈥攂e they observers, colleagues, or friends鈥攖hat despite the slide towards authoritarianism under two decades of Justice and Development Party (AKP) rule, Turkish society still harbors democratic resilience. 

During last May鈥檚 presidential and general elections, outside observers were wary of an opposition victory, arguing that an authoritarian and Islamist leader like Re莽ep Tayyip Erdo臒an would never leave power. As Erdo臒an won the presidential elections, and the opposition bloc failed to secure a majority in the parliament, they must have felt vindicated. 

The 2023 elections were free but unfair. Turkey鈥檚 political playing field is massively tilted in favor of Erdo臒an and his party; the state lavishes funds on his supporters and the media is under government control. Ultimately, the opposition鈥檚 own missteps ushered in Erdo臒an鈥檚 2023 victory. 

Yet, I did not believe that a majority Muslim country in the Middle East could not reverse its trajectory. And women, who tripled their representation in the country鈥檚 mayoral seats, shattered the myth of AKP dominance.  

A stunning opposition victory  

After only ten months, although the playing field remains unequal, the opposition gained a stunning victory in local elections. The March 31 municipal elections marked a historic success for the center left. The secular Republican People鈥檚 Party (CHP), emerged as the leading party for the first time since 1977. The CHP 36 of 81 municipalities鈥攁 vexing setback to the AKP and Erdo臒an. 

The elections were historic as they dispelled the notion that a liberal, secular party would not win in rural, conservative areas. In addition to the three largest metropolitan centers of 陌stanbul, Ankara, and 陌zmir, the CHP won the mayoralties of major cities in conservative Anatolia鈥攕ome for the first time since multiparty elections were held in 1950.鈥&苍产蝉辫;

The change in heart even in traditional AKP strongholds can be attributed to Turkey鈥檚 ongoing economic crisis, as well as changes in opposition leadership. The AKP鈥檚 flawed economic policies of the past decade put the economy in  with galloping inflation, which hit almost 70% year-on-year in 鈥&苍产蝉辫;

Additionally, the CHP has changed its leadership after their defeat in the 2023 elections. Under a younger and more dynamic leadership, the CHP avoided past mistakes and pursued a much better electoral campaign. Disenchanted AKP voters either avoided the ballot box or voted for the opposition, signaling to the government that they did not lack alternatives. 

Women elected in AKP strongholds鈥 

The election results dealt a serious blow to the conviction that women candidates would not be elected in conservative areas and in a patriarchal country like Turkey. 鈥淭he myths suggesting that women cannot win elections and that voters do not vote for women have been debunked,鈥 a statement from the Platform for Equality of Women. 

As a result of the municipal elections, the number of female mayors nearly tripled to 11 of the 81 provinces. Of those, one is from the governing AKP while the remaining are from the CHP and pro-Kurdish DEM Party. The DEM managed to elect female mayors in A臒r谋, Siirt, and Diyarbak谋r, all conservative cities in East and Southeast Anatolia. 

For instance, G眉listan S枚n眉k from DEM Party won 64.5% of the vote in the deeply pious city of Batman, against a candidate from Kurdish-ultra-Islamist, H眉da-Par, who is an Erdo臒an government ally in the nation's parliament. "H眉da-Par did not see me as a competitor because I was a woman," S枚n眉k Reuters. "The last thing they wanted was to lose to a young woman. That makes me incredibly proud." 

Moreover, many initially questioned the CHP鈥檚 choice of Sinem Dedeta艧 as the candidate for the historically conservative 陌stanbul neighborhood of 脺sk眉dar, claiming a woman would fail to lure conservative voters. Yet, the marine engineer won the race by 7% ahead of her AKP rival鈥攁 symbolic blow to Erdo臒an, whose family residence is in 脺sk眉dar. 

Like Dedeta艧, some of the women made history as they became the first female mayors of cities or districts in which they ran. In Afyonkarahisar, Burcu K枚ksal delivered the city鈥檚 top seat to the CHP for the first time in the republic鈥檚 history. 

While meritocracy played a central role in the specific choices for female candidates, opposition parties did not hesitate this time to nominate young names with less experience. Some of the first-time mayors had already served in municipalities or in the national parliament while others came from civil society organizations. 

Women in the democratic fight 

After the country switched from a parliamentary to a presidential system, Erdo臒an needed 51% of the votes to get elected and started luring ultra-Islamist and ultra-conservative parties by compromising women's rights. The regression in women鈥檚 rights and gender equality have grown, culminating in the withdrawal of Turkey from the 陌stanbul Convention, international treaty against domestic violence (for which the AKP had played a major role in preparation during the 2000s).  

As a result of Erdo臒an鈥檚 authoritarian turn and the erosion of women鈥檚 rights, women started to take the front lines resisting democratic backsliding.  

For instance, women in small villages became activists against environmentally detrimental projects planned by the government. Nejla I艧谋k, a woman from 陌kizdere, a small village in the Aegean region was one of the iconic figures of the campaign to stop the destruction of a local forest for the construction of a coal plant. While she has been subjected to intense pressure during her five-year campaign, which failed to bring the desired outcome, she nevertheless was elected the muhtar, or village ruler, in 陌kizdere on March 31. 

鈥淐onservative values and the masculine nature of politics can present significant barriers to women's representation in Turkey, even more so at the local level,鈥 said Professor Evren Balta, the International Relations Department Chair at 脰zye臒in University. 鈥淲inning elections in conservative areas can be seen as a major success for women in such contexts. Furthermore, particularly in majoritarian elections where the race is about one seat, it is usually men who get that one seat as opposed to parliamentary elections where there is proportional representation,鈥 he added.  

"The election took place between two sharp lines. One was the mentality that saw women as second-class, and the other defended women's freedom. The public chose the latter," said  S枚n眉k in her interview with Reuters.鈥 鈥&苍产蝉辫;

This year鈥檚 elections were a democratic triumph, according to Ekrem 陌mamo臒lu, who won 陌stanbul鈥檚 elections for the second time, and are especially significant for Turkey鈥檚 neighboring region. 陌mamo臒lu, who played a critical role in the nomination of women candidates in 陌stanbul, said during his victory speech that Turkish voters became an example for Muslim peoples yearning for freedom and equality and deserving to live in democratic regimes. 

The views expressed in this piece are those of the author and do not express the official position of the 浪花直播 Center.   

Middle East Program

浪花直播鈥檚 Middle East Program serves as a crucial resource for the policymaking community and beyond, providing analyses and research that helps inform US foreign policymaking, stimulates public debate, and expands knowledge about issues in the wider Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region.   Read more

Middle East Program

Middle East Women's Initiative

The Middle East Women's Initiative (MEWI) promotes the empowerment of women in the region through an open and inclusive dialogue with women leaders from the Middle East and continuous research.   Read more

Middle East Women's Initiative